fredag 2 september 2016

Theme 1: Theory of knowledge and theory of science, 1st post


At the end of the discussion of the definition "Knowledge is perception", Socrates argues that we do not see and hear "with" the eyes and the ears, but "through" the eyes and the ears. How are we to understand this? And in what way is it correct to say that Socrates argument is directed towards what we in modern terms call "empiricism"?


By examining the difference of the sensory organs of the body, Socrates and Theaetetus come to the conclusion that certain qualities, or some knowledge, cannot be perceived with the senses, since the senses themselves cannot compare the qualities they sense with each other. As for qualities like temperatures and colours, this is obvious, since the eyes cannot see heat or cold and the skin cannot feel black or white, but for more abstract qualities, like likeness, sameness and quantity, a mind is needed to compare what is perceived and draw the conclusions of these things. So, with this conclusion and the presumption from earlier in the dialogue that truths cannot exist without the act of agent meeting with patient (roughly meaning an abstraction becomes reality after being observed), Socrates and Theaetetus realize that the senses do not pick up truths and knowledge on their own, and that it should be said that different qualities of the world outside the body are picked up ”through” the senses, which may perceive the qualities differently depending on the person and the state the person is in, and only becomes knowledge after becoming a sensation, which then reaches the mind, which reasons about it. Knowledge can only be attained by reason after sensation.

In a way this is the ground-work for the concept of empiricism, which means that knowledge is only what is perceived via the senses, but when speaking of empiricism as a scientific method, things would get a little complicated by the fact that the philosophers already in this initial reasoning – about knowledge being dependent on the intake of sensation through the sensory organs – entertain the thought that what one man sees may differ from what another man sees solely depending on the current state of the sensory organs. With scientific research, we want to understand nature to a degree that we can predict it, thus getting as close as we can to finding the universal laws of nature, but how can we attain any universal knowledge if the knowledge a person acquires depends not only on law of nature, but also on his/her current state? If empiricism is to be used as a scientific method, I suggest the best way would be via statistics. By repeating experiments many times, not only will the occasional errors lose influence by each repetition, but with every new person observing, the sensations that seem to repeat most often are most likely to be the “truest” ones, if one believes in absolute natural laws outside our perception.


In the preface to the second edition of "Critique of Pure Reason" (page B xvi) Kant says: "Thus far it has been assumed that all our cognition must conform to objects. On that presupposition, however, all our attempts to establish something about them a priori, by means of concepts through which our cognition would be expanded, have come to nothing. Let us, therefore, try to find out by experiment whether we shall not make better progress in the problems of metaphysics if we assume that objects must conform to our cognition." How are we to understand this?



Kant at first starts to entertain this concept after discussing the constant dead ends in the “science” of metaphysics. The philosophy that Kant criticizes is based on the assumption that the ways we perceive things are subjective, as discussed in Theaetetus, but that we know things because of our experiences and the reasoning that comes as we gain experience. This causes difficulties with understanding metaphysics though, since we have no way of gaining experience of concepts of the metaphysical nature, like the concept of infinity for example. According to Kant, an object must have a nature “in-itself” (its absolute form, without anybody or anything perceiving it), and so far we have never been able to see an object’s true self, since all perception of an object is subjective, and we constantly try to reason based on our subjective experiences – we let our cognition conform to the object. Thus, he poses the solution that, like Copernicus saw how the Earth revolved around the Sun after shifting perspective, we can change the way we think about the world around us by trying to understand the true nature of objects, their “in-themselves”, and then experience them through that a priori-knowledge.

The theme of the texts concern reality and perception. Before the dialogue with Theaetetus, it is presumed that perception itself is knowledge, but with the help of Socrates, the men conclude with pure reasoning that knowledge and perception are separate things; that the senses may feed the mind sensations, but ultimately, the mind refines the sensations into knowledge, and the sensations may be different for the same object depending on the state of the observer. As for Kant, he wanted mankind to see reality for what it is, and so proposed a revolution to the way of perceiving things.

1 kommentar:

  1. I think that you understand the essence of the text very well. The way you explain the theories and with the given the examples, you applied the theory into our daily life. I agree with you on how we haven't been able to see the true self of an object since our perception of it is subjective. Your drawn conclusion on how the theory of the text should be seen as reality vs. perception is also very interesting. It explained the bases of what Kant and Socrates mean.

    SvaraRadera