söndag 18 september 2016

Theme 1: Theory of knowledge and theory of science, 2nd post



Reading Plato’s Thaeatetus was a bit heavy, but I grasped most of the points and themes pretty well. I learned some additional things about it from the lecture though, for example the way the ancient Greek philosophers viewed the world as teleological and not mechanical certainly gave a clearer picture of their thought processes, like how they include moral concepts such as the good and the evil in the theoretical world as it is itself instead of thinking of them as humanly constructed concepts.

The preface to Kant’s Critiqe of Pure Reason I had some difficulty with though. I felt that I could answer the assignment question quite well – about how we need to change the perspective on how we try to understand the world – but most of the content became much clearer after I re-read it after the lecture. At first, my understanding was that Kant means we will never be able to see the world as it is, so we should study it with the tools (senses and cognitions) we already have and just work from there, but I found it to be a good analogy from the lecture when it was explained as if Kant proposed that we try to step down and see the world from our human point of view, whereas we have been trying all the time to see the world as God sees it.

Another thing that always confused me, even since before this course, was the terms a priori and a posteriori. It is now more clear to me not only that the a priori can be viewed as what we can know about our world before experiencing it, while the a posteriori is what we can only know after experiencing something, but also how we can know things before experiencing them according to Kant.

Kant has divided the ways we perceive the world into 12 different categories. While the neat division of the categories seems a little too convenient for my taste, I agree with him on the whole nonetheless. How we view space, time and shapes etc. seems to be necessary cognitive functions pre-programmed from birth, and fits with my thoughts from before this course on how different the world would look if we had different senses or consciousness.

The most interesting discussion I had at the seminar was how our world view might develop further after the post-Kantian world view we have had for a couple of centuries now. It was hard for many of us to free ourselves from the modern thought that knowledge is always relative to where or when you come from, and I think most of us still agreed to that. But we came up with alternative ways to view the relation between the world “as it is” and the perceived world. For example, a view that I like to stick to, is that the reality (if there even is such a thing to it) of the world “as it is” might just be a world of unimaginable raw data or just is so alien to us that we could never comprehend it (a quite Kantian perspective), but that for each consciousness in existence, it practically creates a new universe, so that there exists 7 billion human universes at once. These were just playful thoughts, but they let us delve a bit into discussions of solipsism as well.

3 kommentarer:

  1. You have expressed your thoughts in a very engaging way. What especially grabbed my attention was your last comment about how people might not be able to comprehend reality as it is and every person might have an interpretation of his own. I have also thought about it but in a slightly different outlook.
    Each of us as humans is safe within his own conciseness as long as he/she brings it to line with rationality and logic. This is how we adjust to and feel comfortable with the world.
    However, our conciseness can also be perceived as our own little universe because of how it keeps our thoughts and knowledge intact. Can we then consider that the mind is a noumenal world for the others since they cannot access nor experience it since it exists apart from their senses?
    Such questions only confirm how it is inevitable not to engage in some form of metaphysical speculations as it gives us under the surface view of the life.

    SvaraRadera
  2. Your thoughts of the world “as it is” compared to our perceived world is intriguing. It would be interesting to imagine that there are senses we lack to fully understand the world as it actually is. Seeing as how science and theories of knowledge have developed, our world view may very well develop into something of this nature.

    I was happy to see that you mentioned solipsism as we did not discuss it in our seminar. The idea that we can only be sure of our own existence is something I thought of when reading Plato’s text. The dialectic between Socrates and Theaetetus seemed to come to no conclusions about what knowledge was. Socrates only concluded that be sure of anyone’s perceptions as they all vary. Therefore, maybe we can only be certain of our own minds and our own existence.

    SvaraRadera
  3. Your thoughts of the world “as it is” compared to our perceived world is intriguing. It would be interesting to imagine that there are senses we lack to fully understand the world as it actually is. Seeing as how science and theories of knowledge have developed, our world view may very well develop into something of this nature.

    I was happy to see that you mentioned solipsism as we did not discuss it in our seminar. The idea that we can only be sure of our own existence is something I thought of when reading Plato’s text. The dialectic between Socrates and Theaetetus seemed to come to no conclusions about what knowledge was. Socrates only concluded that be sure of anyone’s perceptions as they all vary. Therefore, maybe we can only be certain of our own minds and our own existence.

    SvaraRadera